OUR NETWORK:TouchSmart Community TiVo Community TechLore Sling Community MediaSmart Home See all... About UsAdvertiseContact Us

Connecting with DVI

-Syndicated from TechLore.com

DVI (Digital Visual Interface) is the newer digital connector that is quickly replacing VGA connections for hooking up your average flat panel monitor to your PC. Projectors, HDTV's and other digital equipment are also making use of this new connection.

However, the prospect of just going out and picking up a new DVI cable for your connection isn't as easy as it might sound ... something I learned the hard way recently when trying to connect my Media Center PC to my HDTV. So, I thought I'd share a little knowledge I gleaned from that experience.

Single- vs. Dual Channel DVI

The first thing you need to know about DVI is that it can either be single- or dual-channel. In a nutshell, a dual-channel DVI cable can send twice as much information as a single-channel cable. For the most part, a single DVI link consists of four twisted pairs transmitting 2.6 megapixels at 60Hz with a color depth of 24 bits/pixel, giving it approximately the same speed and power of an analog video signal. With a dual-channel cable, there are simply two sets of these four twisted pairs, so twice as much data can be transmitted at the same time.

What does this mean practically? If you desire a resolution of 1024x768 @ 60Hz with 32-bit color (typical resolution for my scenario - hooking my TV up as a glorified monitor), then you would require 1024 * 768 = 786432 pixels = 0.75 megapixels. So, no problem? Well, hold on. A single DVI link transmits at 24 bits/pixel, but this scenario calls for 32 bits/pixel (which is what defines color depth). The specification demands that the leftover 8 bits be sent over the second channel, so a dual-channel connection / cable is required. Something to keep in mind.

What about full HD? If you're pumping out a video signal at 1080i, the calculation is much different. 1080i (standard high-def) is basically 1080 scan lines (hence the name) with 1920 pixels/line, for a total of 1080 * 1920 = 2,071,600 = just shy of 2 megapixels. Again, the second channel is required to get a greater than 24-bit color depth.

So, the net of the discussion is to spring for the dual-channel cable. Even though it's unlikely you'll be hooking up anything that requires a higher resolution than 1920x1440 (which is supports by no LCD monitor you would like own), you probably will want the deeper color depth, you'll want to be prepared for the future, and the cost difference is minimal.

How do I tell the cables apart?

Well, the single-channel vs. dual-channel question isn't the only one to consider here, but it's definitely a factor. Also in play is that newer DVI cables have been built to allow analog signals across them as well. So, if you're going to use a DVI cable to hook up a CRT, that's important to you.

Here's a quick guide on the no-less-than-five different kinds of cables out there, so you can tell them apart. Observe the image above. It pretty much spells out the configuration differences. DVI-I cables support analog and digital connections. DVI-D is for digital connections only ... very commonly sold as just "DVI", which is probably no issue for you because you're most likely wanting to hook up to an LCD monitor, HDTV, or the like -- but be aware of what you're buying. And DVI-A is analog only ... probably not what you're looking for, so be careful of cables priced dramatically less than other cables that sound the same in the limited information a number of sites will give you about the cable prior to purchase. And of course, we've covered the single- vs dual-channel component of the technology.

More Info

In the way of reference, just in case you want to read up on more of this subject, both the image and much of the data in this article come from the DVI entry in the Wikipedia.

Not All My Questions Have Been Answered

So, the last thing I'm left to ponder is as follows. Pretty much everything I've read tells me that DVI and HDMI should be somewhat interchangeable ... that for what I'm doing, either should work. It seems intuitive that it shouldn't make any difference whether or not I hook my HDTV to my PC via a DVI-to-DVI cable or a DVI-to-HDMI cable. But it does. I've tried both, and with the DVI only solution, I can pretty much set my PC to whatever resolution I want at 60Mhz without issue. But with the DVI-to-HDMI connection, I have lots of problems. Above 800x600, the image is totally messed up. It's not blurry, although it's very unreadable. It's like a double image, one a half-inch above the other. It's like there's an interlacing problem, but a DLP TV like mine doesn't work that way, so that's not the problem.

Discussion:    Add a Comment | Comments 1-5 of 5 | Latest Comment

March 7, 2006 10:52 PM

Nice article. What am I missing here? Why would anyone ever purchase an analog DVI cable? Why would they even make them?

DVR + Slingbox = TV Heaven

March 9, 2006 10:34 PM

Something to be careful of - you can't just take a DVD-D cable and connect it from a video card to an HDTV's DVD-D input and expect it to work. Sometimes, this is the case, but none of the ATI cards I've tried to connect this way worked, at least with my TV. Instead, I had to use ATI's component adapter and PowerStrip (the software for HTPC setups). One problem with this connection - you can't watch DVD movies in 720p or 1080i, at least not without help. Macrovision disables 720p and 1080i from DVD sources through component inputs, so software (such as AnyDVD) that strips Macrovision is required.

I now use a Sony DVD player that has an HDMI output for my DVDs (I use a HDMI-DVI cable). DVDs can be upscaled and viewed using 720p or 1080i using this connection.

Some people have tried connecting a DVD player such as mine to a flat-panel monitor's DVI-I input. That doesn't work, as DVI-I doesn't support HDCP.

TechLore Blog

HR10-250, Samsung SIR-S4120R, SIR-S4080R, 2 Philips DSR704s (one connected to a Slingbox A/V). One box used the "Zipper"; rest used PTVnet to enable networking features.

March 22, 2007 6:42 AM

Is it possible to connect VGA with HDMI??

October 8, 2007 2:03 PM

Hi Jeff (or anyone who might be able to help),

 I stumbled upon this site and forum when searching on how to connect my Windows Media Center PC to my HDTV ready Sony Television set - this article is very informative but I thought I would post some details here.

Sony Media Center Edition PC (2005 Edition) - Model # VGC-RA710G

Sony Television Set - Model # KP-46WT510

My video card on the PC has DVI out and the TV has DVI in.  I tried the DVI-D cable which does not use all the pins and I got a double image on the TV set.  I just got a DVI-I cable and have not tried it yet but I'm hopeful that it works.

 The computer does NOT have HDMI output.  Just SVGA and DVI.

All I'm trying to do is get HDTV resolution on my TV out of my PC.  In order to get a true HDTV resolution do I need to have an HDTV video card?  Some of this is over my head although I consider myself very tech savvy...this one I can't seem to get a handle on.

 I understand I will need to get Digital Cable with the set-top box, and not standard (analog) cable but if I can get the resolution right, I will order Digital cable and start watching some of my shows in HD

Any help / advice/ tips on how to get a better resolution that 1024x768 with an S-VGA cable would be great.

Thanks!

-Joel 

February 27, 2008 7:18 AM

Jeff,

Thanks for the excellent article. I still need some help with a problem you described.

Setup: Older HP Media Center PC (2003? not 2005) with vga/dvi card installed (GForce I think.) OS=Windows Media Center which I think is basically XP-Pro with Media capabilities.

           New Sharp 45' HDTV with HDMI inputs plus several other types of inputs.

           HDMI cable 25' long TV to Pc with HDMI/DVI adapter at PC.

Problem: On boot image on TV is perfect until Windws loads then image goes to a ghosted or double image with a slight offset maybe 1/2" on the screen like you described. Image is messy and not usable like this. You can barely read the text etc but can make out the gist of what is on the screen. My intended use is to show internet content for continuing medical eduacation credit to my docs in my medical practice in our staff meeting. Not particularly graphic intensive, slides streaming video etc. of lectures. I've tried all resolutions offered (about 3 or 4) with no difference.

Can you or anyone else advise me about this? Did you come up with a solution to your issue? Is it the Cable? Video card? OS? DVI/HDMI Adapter?

I don't want to start switching out parts randomly without some direction or plan.

Thanks in advance,

DrBob

Discussion:    Add a Comment | Back to Top | Comments 1-5 of 5 | Latest Comment

Add Your Reply

(will not be displayed)

Email me when comments are added to this thread

 
 

Please log in or register to participate in this community!

Log In

Remember

Not a member? Sign up!

Did you forget your password?

You can also log in using OpenID.

close this window
close this window